Beastie Boys
"The words really just came out. The track in a way dictated it, because the track had a more serious or heavier sound to it so we just talked about the idea of writing a song as a letter to New York and then we all just started writing" - Beastie Boys, 2004
Press
"Songs like [this one] pay homage to the city in literal terms. The song sounds like a mash-up remix of a lost, post-disco
New York rock track, with snarling guitars and a buoyant bass line" - MTV News, 2004
"[The album's] standout track, An Open Letter to NYC, should follow Fight for Your Right, So What'cha Want and Sabotage into the Beastie Boys' hall of slang as anthems defining a moment in hip-hop history. Running on the rails of a bubbling keyboard, [this track] is a stylized shout-out to New York City, from Battery Park to Brooklyn. It may be the next phase in the post-9/11 healing process. Where Bruce Springsteen's The Rising was about recovering from wounds, the Beastie Boys' lyrics are about rising from the flames. There is little dark imagery, just a call for unity and Big Apple pride" - Michael D. Clark, Houston Chronicle, 2004
"The set frequently pays homage to the trio's New York surroundings, best heard on [this track]. In front of a chopped-up sample of the Dead Boys' 'Sonic Reducer,' the group finds solace in the city's post-September 11th resiliency: 'Since 911 we're still livin'/and lovin' life we've been given/Ain't nothing gonna take that away from us/we're lookin' pretty and gritty 'cause in the city we trust." - Jonathan Cohen, Billboard, April 2004
"[A] bittersweet ode to post-9/11 New York" - "Beauty of The Beasts" by Richard Ferrer, June 2004
"There's a post-9/11 track called An Open Letter to NYC that's as close as the Beasties ever get to Springsteen-style
solemnity" - Josh Tyrangiel, Time, June 2004
"...a hymn to post-September 11 resilience" - Tom Moon, Inquirer, June 2004
"The terse 'Open Letter' manages to channel that city's post 9/11 resolve without sounding like a Bruce Springsteen song" - Sam Chennault, Houston Press, June 2004
"...[the album's] highlight" - Associated Press, June 14, 2004
"...tells the real story of the threesome in 2004: post-Sept. 11 New Yorkers looking at the world around them and wondering,
'What's going on?'" - Billboard, June 15, 2004
"Snappy rhymes and sonic thump combine in a winning display of Beastie economy, a formula the Boys fail to apply uniformly."
- Edna Gundersen, USA Today, June 15, 2004
"From the beginning they have always rapped about the great New York City and this time it's no different. It starts with the title of the album and stretches to [this] song; it reminisces of their growing up and living in New York." - Josh Cannon, Indiana Statesman, June 16, 2004
"[Beastie Boys] sound heartfelt in their New York state of mind, especially the affecting on [this track]" - Russell Baillie, New Zealand Herald, June 19, 2004
"...harmless, political rhymes..." - Chloe Sasson,
Sydney Morning Herald, June 23, 2004
"...affectionate if somewhat corny" - Chuck Arnold, People, July 12, 2004 |